Upcoming Webinars Archived Webinars Training Vitals Host A Webinar About Get Updates Contact

UPDATE: FDA Commissioner Calls For Retraction Of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy Drug Study

XTALKS VITALS NEWS

Dr. Robert Califf

According to Califf, the study is “misleading” and should be removed from the journal, Annals of Neurology, where it was published.

Tweetables from this article:

Tweet: According to Califf, the Sarepta study is “misleading” and should be removed from the journal http://ctt.ec/a1sDh+According to Califf, the Sarepta study is “misleading” and should be removed from the journal.

Share this!

September 23, 2016 | by Sarah Hand, M.Sc.

Just days after Sarepta Therapeutics’ eteplirsen became the first US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved treatment for Duchenne muscular dystrophy, the agency’s commissioner Dr. Robert Califf is calling for the drug study to be retracted. According to Califf, the study is “misleading” and should be removed from the journal, Annals of Neurology, where it was published.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is a rare genetic disease which causes steadily worsening muscle deterioration and results in early death. While patients and their families rejoiced following news that Sarepta’s drug was approved, the decision caused upset within the FDA with some officials questioning the drug’s ability to benefit patients.

The dispute in question is over the findings of a 2013 study of eteplirsen, which was funded by Sarepta. The study found that the drug – marketed as Exondys 51 – triggered production of the protein dystrophin, which is important in muscle integrity.

The study claimed that the injectable drug helped the patients generate enough dystrophin to allow them to walk. But Califf, along with others at the FDA, disagrees with the study authors’ interpretations.



“The publication, now known to be misleading, should probably be retracted by its authors,” said Califf in a memo on the dispute regarding accelerated approval of the drug. “… In view of the scientific deficiencies identified in this analysis, I believe it would be appropriate to initiate a dialogue that would lead to a formal correction or retraction (as appropriate) of the published report.”

Califf is not alone is his skepticism of the study. Dr. Luciana Borio, the FDA acting chief scientist said, “As determined by the review team, and as acknowledged by Dr. Woodcock, the article’s scientific findings — with respect to the demonstrated effect of eteplirsen on both surrogate and clinical endpoints — do not withstand proper and objective analyses of the data. It is very disappointing that the findings did not hold up to careful review.”

It’s unclear whether Califf and his associates’ call for the paper to be retracted will be upheld by the journal. But the journal’s editor, Dr. Clifford Saper, offered his opinion on the dispute.

“It takes more than a call by a politician for retraction of a paper,” said Saper. “It takes actual evidence.

“If you read the FDA report, you will quickly realize that it was the result of internal political squabbling within the FDA. At this point, because I am neither a politician nor a drug company representative, I have no opinion on the matter. I will wait for someone who is responsible to send me evidence of a problem, so that I can, if need be, investigate further.”


Keywords: FDA, Muscular Dystrophy, Drug Approval


| NEXT ARTICLE | MORE NEWS | BLOGS | VIDEOS | POLLS & QUIZZES | WEBINARS |

Share this with your colleagues!

MORE NEWS
Amgen Identifies Issue with Patient Access to PCSK9 Inhibitor

March 23, 2017 - Most US patients hoping to get their PCSK9 inhibitor medications covered by their prescription drug plan are being denied, according to two new studied conducted by Amgen.

Featured In: Biotech News


Smartphone App Created Using Apple’s ResearchKit Used to Conduct Asthma Clinical Studies

March 22, 2017 - Researchers at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai have conducted a large-scale, observational study of asthma patients using the Apple ResearchKit framework and the Asthma Health app on patients’ iPhones.

Featured In: Clinical Trials News


IBS Patients Taking Viberzi May Be at Increased Risk of Pancreatitis

March 22, 2017 - According to a recent drug safety communication issued by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), patients with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) with diarrhea should not be treated using Viberzi (eluxadoline), if they do not have a gallbladder.

Featured In: Drug Safety News

LEAVE A COMMENT
 
  
THE XTALKS VITALS LIFE SCIENCE BLOG

Will Pharmaceutical Serialization Solve All of Our Drug Counterfeiting Problems?

REGISTER FOR THESE WEBINARS

How to Improve the Speed and Efficiency of Your Clinical Trials


High Performance Computing for High Content Screening - A Case Study


The FDA Guidance on the Assessment of Abuse Potential of Drug – A Critical Review


Treatment of Psoriasis: Improvements Through Clinical Trials


Copyright © 2016-2017 Honeycomb Worldwide Inc.